< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Approve XACML 2.0 as an OASIS Standard

Should the eXtensible Access Control Markup Language (XACML) Version 2.0 Committee Draft 04 from the OASIS eXtensible Access Control Markup Language (XACML) TC be approved as an OASIS standard?

 [ ]  Yes
 [ ]  No
Opening:   Monday, 17 January 2005 @ 10:00 am EST
Closing:   Monday, 31 January 2005 @ 11:45 pm EST
Group:   OASIS organizational voting
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name Type Date Action
Reference Document
2005-01-17

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
Yes 67 100%
No 0 0%
Eligible companies who have voted: 67 of 349 19%
Eligible companies who have abstained: 0 of 349 0%
Eligible companies who have not voted: 282 of 349 81%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
Jung-in Choi (Pri)
ACOGITO co.Ltd
--
 
Danny Vint (Pri)
ACORD
--
 
Arnaud Bezancon (Pri)
ADVANTYS
--
 
Isao Kojima (Pri)
AIST
--
 
Roger Martin (Pri)
AOL
Yes
 
Haruo Naito (Pri)
ATL Systems Incorporated
--
 
Gregory O'Malley (Pri)
Abridean, Inc.
--
 
Anthony Roby (Pri)
Accenture
--
 
Dyfan Williams (Pri)
Accountis plc
--
 
Daniel Foody (Pri)
Actional Corporation
--
 
Christopher Keller (Pri)
Active Endpoints, Inc.
--
 
Duane Nickull (Pri)
Adobe Systems
Yes
 
Geoffrey Strongin (Pri)
Advanced Micro Devices
--
 
Franck DULUC (Pri)
Airbus
--
 
Nga Cao (Pri)
Allette Systems (Australia) Pty Ltd
Yes
 
Steven Hammond (Pri)
Allmerica Financial
--
 
Raj Nooyi (Pri)
AmSoft Systems
--
 
fred carter (Pri)
AmberPoint
Yes
 
PG Bartlett (Pri)
Arbortext, Inc.
--
 
Frank Siebenlist (Pri)
Argonne National Laboratory
Yes
 
Karl Heckart (Pri)
Arizona Supreme Court
--
 
Steve Caughey (Pri)
Arjuna Technologies Limited
--
 
David Smiley (Pri)
Ascential Software
--
 
Florencio Vilchez (Pri)
Asociación Nacional de Fabricantes Autoridad de Certificació
--
 
Didier COURTAUD (Pri)
Association Aristote
--
 
John Hughes (Pri)
Atos Origin
Yes
 
Jean-Jacques Dubray (Alt)
Attachmate
Yes
 
John Lalor (Pri)
Australian Government Information Management Office
--
 
Brett Anderson (Pri)
Australian Taxation Office
--
 
Kevin O'Kane (Pri)
Auto-trol Technology Corporation
--
 
Pat Snack (Pri)
Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG)
--
 
William Perry (Pri)
Aventail Corp
--
 
Bernard Manouvrier (Pri)
Axway software
--
 
Howard Mason (Pri)
BAE SYSTEMS plc
--
 
Muthu Ramadoss (Pri)
BAHWAN CYBERTEK INC
Yes
 
Hal Lockhart (Pri)
BEA Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Doron Cohen (Pri)
BMC Software
--
 
Graham Cook (Pri)
BTplc
--
 
Jack Zhang (Pri)
Beijing Harmony Technologies Co, Ltd
--
 
Didier Leemans (Pri)
Belgian Federal Public Service FINANCE
--
 
Karl-Heinz Krueger (Pri)
Beta Systems Software AG
--
 
Michael Fergusson (Pri)
Blast Radius Inc.
--
 
Leslie Sagalowicz (Pri)
Blazent
--
 
Frank Martinez (Pri)
Blue Titan Software
--
 
Joseph Chiusano (Pri)
Booz Allen Hamilton
Yes
 
Peter Reynolds (Pri)
Bowne Global Solutions
Yes
 
Even Thorbergsen (Pri)
Bronnoysund Register Centre
--
 
Philip Lee (Pri)
Business Process Management Initiative (BPMI.org)
--
 
John Ketchell (Pri)
CEN/ISSS
--
 
John Chelsom (Pri)
CSW Group Ltd.
--
 
christopher smith (Pri)
California Administrative Office of the Courts
--
 
Ned Allison (Pri)
California Legislative Data Center
--
 
leslie-ann scott (Pri)
Canada Customs & Revenue Agency
--
 
James Pasley (Pri)
Cape Clear Software
--
 
XiaoDong Lee (Pri)
China Internet Network Information Center(CNNIC)
Yes
 
Peter Furniss (Pri)
Choreology Ltd
--
 
Chung-Ming Ou (Pri)
Chunghwa Telecom Laboratories
--
 
Krishna Sankar (Pri)
Cisco Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Carl Banzhof (Pri)
Citadel Security Software, Inc.
--
 
Rob van der Linden (Pri)
Citrix Systems
Yes
 
Mavis Cournane (Pri)
Cognitran
--
 
Don Campbell (Pri)
Cognos Incorporated
--
 
Robert Roper (Pri)
Colorado Judicial Branch
--
 
Fulton Wilcox (Pri)
Colts Neck Solutions LLC
Yes
 
John Cook (Pri)
ComBrio Inc.
--
 
DeLeys Brandman (Pri)
CommerceNet
--
 
David Burdett (Pri)
CommerceOne
--
 
Paul Lipton (Pri)
Computer Associates
Yes
 
Kent Nutt (Pri)
Conformative Systems
--
 
Brad Gandee (Pri)
ContentGuard
--
 
Kirk McElwain (Pri)
Continental Automated Buildings Association (CABA)
--
 
Drummond Reed (Pri)
Cordance
Yes
 
Kenneth Lim (Pri)
CrimsonLogic Pte Ltd
--
 
Eric Leach (Pri)
Critical Path
--
 
Winfield Wagner (Pri)
Crossflo Systems Inc.
Yes
 
Simeon Sheye (Pri)
Cryptomathic a/s
--
 
Pieter Kasselman (Pri)
Cybertrust
--
 
Dale Moberg (Pri)
Cyclone Commerce
Yes
 
Karl Bosch (Pri)
DHH-OPH
--
 
(Dr) Zoran Milosevic (Pri)
DSTC Pty Ltd
--
 
Robert Brentrup (Pri)
Dartmouth College
--
 
Eugene Kuznetsov (Pri)
Datapower Technology, Inc
--
 
Mark Johnson (Pri)
Debian
--
 
Winston Bumpus (Pri)
Dell
--
 
Brian Nielsen (Pri)
Denmark Ministry of Science, Technology & Innovation
--
 
Nils Sandsmark (Pri)
Det Norske Veritas
--
 
Sastry Dhara (Pri)
Dhara Consulting Group, Inc.
--
 
Yola Park (Pri)
Diderot Track BV
--
 
Christoph Bussler (Pri)
Digital Enterprise Research Institute (DERI)
--
 
Gary Ham (Pri)
Disaster Management Interoperability Services
--
 
Una Kearns (Pri)
Documentum
--
 
Suresh Ramaswamy (Pri)
Dralasoft, Inc.
--
 
Matt Walton (Pri)
E Team
--
 
Gilbert Pilz (Pri)
E2Open
--
 
Kyu-Chul Lee (Pri)
ECIF
--
 
Joseph Moeller (Pri)
EDS
--
 
Mario Antonioletti (Pri)
EPCC, The University of Edinburgh
--
 
Adarbad Master (Pri)
EPOK, Inc.
--
 
David Danko (Pri)
ESRI
--
 
Rich Harwell (Pri)
Eaton
--
 
Vijay Dhingra (Pri)
Echelon Corporation
--
 
Jean-Luc LEVESQUE (Pri)
EdiEyes
--
 
Hisanao Sugamata (Pri)
Electronic Commerce Promotion Council of Japan
--
 
Ki Young Moon (Pri)
Electronics and Telecommunications Research Institute(ETRI)
Yes
 
graphics graphics (Pri)
Ematek Informatik GMBH
--
 
Steve Ross-Talbot (Pri)
Enigmatec Corporation Ltd
--
 
Chris Louden (Pri)
Enspier
--
 
Tim Moses (Pri)
Entrust
Yes
 
Gosta Linder (Pri)
Ericsson
--
 
Barak Perlman (Pri)
Etagon
--
 
Hakan Karden (Pri)
Eurostep Group AB
--
 
Chris Borneman (Pri)
Exostar, LLC
--
 
Andrew Stern (Pri)
F5 Networks, Inc
--
 
Nigel Ratcliffe (Pri)
Factiva
--
 
Barbara Held (Pri)
Federal Ministry of the Interior, Germany
--
 
paul gallivan (Pri)
Fidelity Investments
--
 
Mike Marin (Pri)
FileNet Corporation
--
 
Steve Hernandes (Pri)
First Data Corporation
--
 
Maciej Szefler (Pri)
FiveSight Technologies
--
 
Thomas Lippert (Pri)
Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH
--
 
Dana Kaufman (Pri)
Forum Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Olivier Dubuisson (Pri)
France Telecom
--
 
Martin Hagen (Pri)
Free Hanseatic City of Bremen / OSCI Co-ordination Office
--
 
Motoyuki Watanabe (Pri)
Fuji Xerox Co., Ltd.
--
 
Masahiko Narita (Pri)
Fujitsu
Yes
 
Amir Jafri (Pri)
FundSERV Inc.
--
 
Ron Lake (Pri)
Galdos Systems Inc
Yes
 
Pierre Vannel (Pri)
Gemplus
--
 
John Jackson (Pri)
General Motors
Yes
 
Marion Royal (Pri)
General Services Administration
--
 
Kefeng Chen (Pri)
GeoTrust
--
 
Mark Kindl (Pri)
Georgia Tech Research Institute
--
 
Gil Perez (Pri)
Gilo Ventures
--
 
jeffery eck (Pri)
Global Exchange Services
--
 
Winston Damarillo (Pri)
GlueCode Software
Yes
 
Jim Hughes (Alt)
Hewlett-Packard
Yes
 
Bradley Bebee (Pri)
Hicks and Associates Inc
--
 
Rob Zivney (Pri)
Hirsch Electronics
--
 
Matsuki Yoshino (Pri)
Hitachi
Yes
 
Kazuyoshi Tanaka (Pri)
Hitachi Systems & Services, Ltd.
--
 
Roy Kolasa (Pri)
Honeywell International, Inc.
--
 
Ranjeeth Thunga (Pri)
HumanMarkup.org, Inc.
--
 
Ivan Futo (Pri)
Hungarian Tax and Financial Control Administration
--
 
Michael Weiner (Pri)
IBM
Yes
 
Trevor Naidoo (Pri)
IDS Scheer
--
 
Chris Branton (Pri)
IEM
--
 
William J. Wagner (Pri)
IFPMM
--
 
Wayne Starr (Pri)
IFS DEFENCE LTD
--
 
EDUARDO SOBERANIS ROMERO (Pri)
INFOTEC-CONACYT-FIDEICOMISO
--
 
Eric Newcomer (Pri)
IONA
Yes
 
James Mason (Pri)
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC34
--
 
Dieter Weidenbruck (Pri)
ITEDO Software GmbH
--
 
Dianne Kennedy (Pri)
IdeAlliance
--
 
John Walsh (Pri)
Indiana University
--
 
Art Botterell (Alt)
Individual
Yes
 
Vishwanath Shenoy (Pri)
Infosys Technologies
--
 
Pina Hirano (Pri)
Infoteria
--
 
Jim Bole (Pri)
Infravio, Inc.
--
 
Dave Roberts (Pri)
Inkra Networks
--
 
Jack Abuhoff (Pri)
Innodata Corporation
--
 
Wei-Jung Lin (Pri)
Institute for Information Industry, STLC
--
 
Terri Tracey (Pri)
Institute for Supply Management
--
 
Assaf Arkin (Pri)
Intalio, Inc.
--
 
Albert Fuss (Pri)
Intelligent Communication Software GmbH
--
 
Milo Scheeren (Pri)
International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation
--
 
Michael Steidl (Pri)
International Press & Telecommunications Council (IPTC)
--
 
Ken Klingenstein (Pri)
Internet2
--
 
Rajesh Pradhan (Pri)
Iopsis Software
--
 
Andrew Comas (Pri)
JPMorganChase
--
 
Byron Hill (Pri)
Johnson Controls, Inc.
--
 
Alex Vasilevsky (Pri)
Katana Technology, Inc
Yes
 
Ron Rasmussen (Pri)
KnowNow Inc.
--
 
Deuk Jin Jung (Pri)
Korea Institute for Electronic Commerce
--
 
Minsoo Kim (Pri)
Korean National Computerization Agency
Yes
 
John Ruegg (Pri)
LA County Information Systems Advisory Body
Yes
 
Mark Crawford (Pri)
LMI Government Consulting
--
 
Mark Pearson (Pri)
LSC Group Ltd
--
 
Don Larson (Pri)
Larson Software Technology
--
 
Randi Mayes (Pri)
LawNet, Inc.
--
 
Mary Thompson (Pri)
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Yes
 
Richard Mark (Pri)
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
--
 
Reinhard Schaler (Pri)
Limerick Localisation Research Centre
--
 
mike mike (Pri)
Localization Industry Standards Assoc. (LISA)
--
 
James Crawford (Pri)
Lockheed Martin
--
 
Paul Allen (Pri)
Logistics Business Systems
--
 
Barry Haaser (Pri)
LonMark International
Yes
 
Wayne Zeuch (Pri)
Lucent Technologies
Yes
 
Lawrence Catchpole (Pri)
M1 Global Solutions
--
 
Gabe Minton (Pri)
MISMO
--
 
Joseph Wheeler (Pri)
MTG Management Consultants, LLC.
Yes
 
Randall Anderson (Pri)
Macgregor
--
 
Robert Kidwell (Pri)
ManTech Enterprise Integration Center (e-IC)
--
 
John Vrankovich (Pri)
Manugistics
--
 
David Goodwin (Pri)
Maricopa County
Yes
 
Benjamin Grosof (Pri)
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
--
 
Michael Daconta (Pri)
McDonald Bradley
--
 
Ido Sarig (Pri)
Mercury Interactive Corp
--
 
Greg Carter (Pri)
Metastorm
--
 
Darin Layman (Pri)
Micromuse Inc.
--
 
Christopher Kurt (Pri)
Microsoft Corporation
--
 
Robin Gibson (Pri)
Missouri Office of State Courts Admin.
Yes
 
Doraiswamy ('Raj') Rajagopal (Pri)
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Milan Karasek (Pri)
Moravia IT
--
 
Heather Kirksey (Pri)
Motive, Inc.
--
 
Bob Benedict (Pri)
NASA
--
 
Takashi Kojo (Pri)
NEC Corporation
--
 
Lynne Rosenthal (Pri)
NIST
Yes
 
Atsuhiro Goto (Pri)
NTT
--
 
Yukio Hashida (Pri)
NTT USA
--
 
Simon Davis (Pri)
National Archives of Australia
--
 
Scott Fairholm (Pri)
National Center for State Courts
--
 
Rick Grimm (Pri)
National Institute of Governmental Purchasing
--
 
Torsten Kirschner (Pri)
National Insurance Administration
--
 
Beth Weston (Pri)
National Library of Medicine
--
 
Richard Hansberger (Pri)
National Notary Association
Yes
 
Kurt Roemer (Alt)
NetContinuum
--
 
Marc Chanliau (Pri)
Netegrity, Inc.
--
 
Harm-Jan van Burg (Pri)
Netherlands Tax and Customs Administration
--
 
Jean-Luc Schellens (Pri)
Netmino
--
 
Jeff Pollock (Pri)
Network Inference
--
 
Peter Davis (Pri)
Neustar, Inc.
Yes
 
Frederick Hirsch (Pri)
Nokia
Yes
 
Nozomu Nemoto (Alt)
Nomura Research Institute, Ltd. (NRI)
Yes
 
Tor Arne Irgens (Pri)
Norwegian Defence Logistics Organisation
--
 
Jim O'Donnell (Pri)
OPT2VOTE Ltd
--
 
Mark Lee (Pri)
OSA Technologies
--
 
Paul Thorpe (Alt)
OSS Nokalva
Yes
 
James Nemiah (Pri)
Object Management Group
--
 
Charles Knouse (Pri)
Oblix
--
 
Pamela Gennusa (Pri)
Ontopia
--
 
David Connelly (Pri)
Open Applications Group
--
 
Carl Reed (Pri)
Open GIS Consortium (OGC)
Yes
 
Tim Howes (Pri)
Opsware Inc.
--
 
Surendra Reddy (Pri)
Optena Corporation
--
 
Martin Chapman (Pri)
Oracle
--
 
Allen Jensen (Pri)
Orange County Superior Court
--
 
Matthew Dovey (Pri)
Oxford University
--
 
Catherine Williams (Pri)
PISCES Ltd
--
 
Yasuyuki Nishioka (Pri)
PSLX consortium
--
 
Jim Clune (Pri)
Parasoft
--
 
Setrag Khoshafian (Pri)
Pegasystems Inc.
--
 
Simon Wall (Pri)
Pennant International Group plc
--
 
Michael Hillerman (Pri)
PeopleSoft
--
 
Marlon Pierce (Pri)
Pervasive Technology Labs at Indiana University
--
 
Robin Basham (Pri)
Phoenix Business & Systems Process, Inc.
--
 
Darren Platt (Pri)
Ping Identity Corporation
Yes
 
Fubini Ross (Pri)
Plumtree Software
--
 
Pravin Gupta (Pri)
Polaris Software Lab Ltd
Yes
 
Doug Ransom (Pri)
Power Measurement
--
 
Yael Gavish-Tabor (Pri)
Qlusters
--
 
Gerhard Eschelbeck (Pri)
Qualys
--
 
Rob Philpott (Pri)
RSA Security
Yes
 
Ash Parikh (Pri)
Raining Data Corporation
--
 
Rob Frankland (Pri)
Rascal Software
--
 
Naren Nagpal (Pri)
ReadiMinds Systems & Services Pte Ltd
--
 
Jeff Honious (Pri)
Reed Elsevier
--
 
Woodruff Jeffrey (Pri)
Reuters
--
 
Yohei Yamamoto (Pri)
Ricoh Company, Ltd.
--
 
Allen Brookes (Pri)
Rogue Wave Software
--
 
Nigel. A Walker (Pri)
Rolls-Royce plc
--
 
Paul Tearnen (Pri)
RosettaNet
--
 
stuart mcfarlane (Pri)
SAA Consultants
--
 
Claus von Riegen (Pri)
SAP
--
 
David Pooley (Pri)
SDL International
--
 
Gerard te Vaanhold (Pri)
SGML/XML Users Group Holland
--
 
Babak Sadighi (Pri)
SICS, Swedish Institute of Computer Science AB
Yes
 
Kevin Heineman (Pri)
SPI Dynamics, Inc.
--
 
Carl Wilen (Pri)
Saab AB
--
 
Coumara Radja (Pri)
Sarvega
--
 
catherine plummer (Pri)
Search Group, Inc.
Yes
 
Christopher Frank (Pri)
Seeburger, AG
--
 
Lluis Mora (Pri)
Sentryware
--
 
Brian Carroll (Pri)
Serena
--
 
Stewart Jack (Pri)
Sierra Systems
--
 
Jahan Moreh (Pri)
Sigaba Corp.
--
 
Eng Wah Lee (Pri)
Singapore Institute of Manufacturing Technology
--
 
Patrick Durusau (Pri)
Society of Biblical Literature (SBL)
Yes
 
Stuart Schaefer (Pri)
Softricity, Inc.
--
 
Glen Daniels (Pri)
Sonic Software
--
 
jaime siegel (Pri)
Sony Electronics, Inc.
--
 
Justin Brunt (Pri)
Staffware plc
--
 
Brian Dirking (Pri)
Stellent
--
 
Suresh Damodaran (Pri)
Sterling Commerce
--
 
Eduardo Gutentag (Pri)
Sun Microsystems
Yes
 
Joyce Kern (Pri)
Sungard Availability Services
--
 
Dimitri Andivahis (Pri)
Surety, Inc
--
 
Mats Elgh (Pri)
Swedish Defence Materiel Administration
Yes
 
Hari Balakrishnan (Pri)
Sybase
--
 
Susie Chua (Pri)
Symlabs, S.A.
--
 
Polar Humenn (Pri)
Syracuse University
Yes
 
Forrest Carpenter (Pri)
System Development, Inc.
--
 
Petr Dvorak (Pri)
Systinet
--
 
Jan Brissman (Pri)
TAC AB
--
 
JACQUES GOUIMENOU (Pri)
TIGA TECHNOLOGIES
--
 
Magnus Martikainen (Pri)
TRADOS Inc.
--
 
Jerry Johnson (Pri)
Texas Department of Information Resources
--
 
Charles Tichenor (Pri)
The Associated Press
--
 
Kathryn Breininger (Pri)
The Boeing Company
Yes
 
Michael Nguyen (Pri)
The Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore
Yes
 
Christopher Crowhurst (Pri)
Thomson Corporation
--
 
Subra Mayilvahanan (Pri)
Thor Technologies
--
 
Ian Hunter (Pri)
Tibco
--
 
Kangbum Ahn (Pri)
TmaxSoft
--
 
John Petze (Pri)
Tridium, Inc.
--
 
Miel De Schepper (Pri)
Trisoft
--
 
Jeff Brantley (Pri)
Troux Technologies
--
 
Sean Mehan (Pri)
UHI Millennium Institute
--
 
Andy Greener (Pri)
UK Inland Revenue eService Programme
--
 
John Borras (Pri)
UK Local e-Government Standards Body
Yes
 
Andrew Moorhouse (Pri)
UK Ministry of Defence Technical Information
--
 
Jerry Smith (Pri)
US Department of Defense (DoD
--
 
Martin Smith (Pri)
US Department of Homeland Security
Yes
 
Charles Grymes (Pri)
US Department of the Interior
--
 
Michael Jacobs (Pri)
US Dept of the Navy
--
 
Susan Smoter (Pri)
US IRS, Internet Development Service
--
 
Dave Glende (Pri)
Unify Corporation
--
 
Daniel Feygin (Pri)
UnitSpace
Yes
 
Paul Donohoe (Pri)
Universal Postal Union
--
 
David Cheung (Pri)
University of Hong Kong
--
 
Mark Mc Keown (Pri)
University of Manchester
--
 
Toby Considine (Pri)
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
--
 
David De Roure (Pri)
University of Southampton
--
 
Roger Reich (Pri)
VERITAS Software
--
 
Gabriel Wachob (Pri)
VISA International
--
 
Phillip Hallam-Baker (Pri)
Verisign
--
 
John Glaubitz (Pri)
Vertex
--
 
Edward Coyne (Pri)
Veterans Health Administration
Yes
 
Michael Sneddon (Pri)
Victorian Society for Computers and the Law, Inc.
--
 
Jeff Collins (Pri)
Vignette Corporation
--
 
Josh Karp (Pri)
Visionael
--
 
Alberto Martin-Briega (Pri)
Vodafone Group services
--
 
Michael Bunyard (Pri)
Voyence, Inc.
--
 
Welf Löwe (Pri)
WSCC
--
 
Elysa Jones (Pri)
Warning Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
tom clarke (Pri)
Washington State Administrator for the Courts
Yes
 
Steve Orrin (Pri)
Watchfire
Yes
 
Amar Lakhtakia (Pri)
Webify Solutions, Inc.
--
 
Michael McCormick (Pri)
Wells Fargo
Yes
 
Darlene Thomas (Pri)
West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources
--
 
Maneesh Sahu (Pri)
Westbridge Technology
--
 
David Kuilman (Pri)
Wolters Kluwer
--
 
Layna Fischer (Pri)
Workflow Management Coalition (WfMC)
--
 
Bill Washburn (Pri)
XDI.ORG
--
 
Marian Lewandowski (Pri)
Xenos Group Inc.
--
 
Mason Ng (Pri)
Yahoo!
--
 
Goran Zugic (Pri)
ebXMLsoft
--
 
Ralph Stout (Pri)
iWay Software
--
 
James Tauber (Pri)
mValent, Inc
--
 
Marc Breissinger (Pri)
webMethods, Inc.
Yes