OASIS Open: Committees

Approve Change Tracking WD 04 as CND 01

Shall the TC approve "ODF Change Tracking: Analysis and Proposals Version 1.0" WD04 as a Committe Note Draft 01?

http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/document.php?document_id=44677&wg_abbrev=office

Opening:		Tuesday, 20 December 2011 @ 06:00 am UTC
Closing:		Saturday, 7 January 2012 @ 11:59 pm UTC
Group:		OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC

Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name	Type	Date	Action
02161: Approve Change Tracking WD 04 as CND 01 (20K)	Document	2012-01-07	Details

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Eligible members who have voted:	10 of 16	63%
Eligible members who have abstained:	2 of 16	13%
Eligible members who have not voted:	4 of 16	25%

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Andre Rebentisch	Ars Aperta	No	Document mentions consent of the SC. Given that technical persons listed as SC members (and in the document) voted "no" in the TC ballot (which should be an approval row) that doesn't seem to be the c
Tristan Mitchell	DeltaXML Limited	Yes
Robin LaFontaine	DeltaXML Limited	Yes	Formal reference to ODF 1.2 needs to be included in references section.
Rob Weir	IBM	--
Mingfei Jia	IBM	--
Donald Harbison	IBM	Yes
Oliver-Rainer Wittmann	IBM	Yes
Louis Suarez-Potts	Individual	--
Patrick Durusau	Individual	Abstain	As it stands now, the ballot as a 40% disapproval score. I think more work needs to be done reaching a consensus in the SC/TC on this item.
Svante Schubert	Individual	No	1) Insufficient specification of the minimum set of functionality to be support ODF interoperability 2) Compatibility for collaboration has not been provided, although it would be possible and is th
Andreas Guelzow	Individual	No	I find any change tracking specification that ignores spreadsheets or assumes that consumers/producers have an internal xml model to be not acceptable.
Dennis Hamilton	Individual	Yes
Cherie Ekholm	Microsoft	Yes
Thorsten Zachmann	Nokia Corporation	Abstain
Thorsten Behrens	Novell	No	As it stands, there are no convincing reasons to give this document any special blessing from TC level, as it's available to the general public already. Conversely, with my TC hat on, I'd rather se
Steven Pemberton	Stichting Centrum voor Wiskunde & Informatica	--